Video underestimates California’s capability to accommodate electrical automobiles and recycle their batteries – PolitiFact

By | August 15, 2022

Our solely agenda is to publish the reality so that you might be an knowledgeable participant in democracy.
We’d like your assist.
Extra Data
As a part of his $10 billion zero-emission car plan to combat local weather change, California Gov. Gavin Newsom needs to part out gasoline-powered automobiles in favor of electrical powered ones by 2035. And President Joe Biden’s Inflation Discount Act, handed Aug. 7 by the U.S. Senate, would give Individuals a tax credit score of as much as $7,500 to defray the price of shopping for an electrical car.
However an Instagram put up claims issue with recycling lithium-ion batteries, the gasoline cells in electrical autos, will render this push towards zero-emission autos impractical.
A video posted June 9 and shared by others includes a lady speaking about California officers advocating for extra renewable vitality and for residents to drive electrical automobiles.
The lady makes a number of claims, together with that the push for extra electrical automobiles just isn’t a “sustainable resolution” as there isn’t a plant in California that may recycle their batteries as soon as they die.
“There’s solely three (electrical automotive battery recycling vegetation) in the US, and so they can solely recycle about 10% of the supplies, which suggests the stability will go into landfills,” she says. “This might do extra injury to our planet in a matter of 10 years than fossil fuels have executed in 100 years.”
The put up was flagged as a part of Fb’s efforts to fight false information and misinformation on its Information Feed. Instagram is owned by Fb’s mother or father firm, Meta. (Learn extra about our partnership with Fb.)
Whereas the girl was proper in saying California does not have a plant devoted to recycling electrical automotive batteries, the state of affairs is not as dire as she claimed. The lady was additionally flawed in her assertion concerning the recyclability of lithium-ion automotive batteries. 
Most electrical automotive batteries final a minimum of 100,000 miles earlier than their capability to carry a cost critically degrades, in accordance with Carfax. With Individuals driving a mean of 13,476 miles every year, that interprets to a minimum of seven years of dependable service.
Most batteries will go for considerably longer than the preliminary 100,000 miles earlier than dying.
The primary main wave of electrical automotive batteries dying off is anticipated to occur throughout the subsequent 10 to fifteen years, the BBC reported.
Not like lead-acid batteries, that are small and simply recyclable, electrical automobiles use battery packs which might be bigger and composed of lots of of particular person lithium-ion batteries. The hazardous supplies inside a battery pack can spark a fireplace or explode if dealt with or disposed of incorrectly.
Additionally, California lacks an electrical automotive battery recycling plant; there are solely 5 such services at the moment working within the U.S.
Nonetheless, Alissa Kendall, a UC Davis civil and environmental engineering professor, advised PolitiFact that California not having a recycling facility was a “notably irrelevant” level, as there are “many issues we recycle or course of within the U.S. economic system that don’t have a website in each state.”
Kendall stated Nevada-based Redwood Supplies launched an electrical automotive battery recycling program in California in February and partnered with California automotive dealerships and battery dismantlers to gather lithium-ion batteries. The batteries shall be despatched to Redwood’s recycling facility in Nevada.
Kendall was the lead creator of a California Environmental Safety Company report in Could that stated electrical automotive battery recycling was a comparatively new, however rising trade.The report additionally made a number of suggestions to the California Legislature for bettering  electrical automotive battery recycling.
In the meantime, there are a number of methods  to recycle electrical automotive batteries, all of which reclaim considerably extra materials than the ten% the Instagram video cited.
One methodology is thru smelting, which melts a battery down at a excessive temperature till its supplies separate from each other. As a result of this methodology requires quite a lot of greenhouse gas-producing vitality however recovers solely about 40% to 50% of a battery’s materials, it’s much less extensively used, the Canadian Broadcasting Corp. reported..
The opposite two recycling strategies, that are extra extensively used, contain shredding lithium-ion batteries into small items.
A shredded battery might be recycled immediately, by eradicating and separating its components by hand, or via hydrometallurgy, wherein the batteries’ items are submerged in an answer and chemically separated. These shredding strategies can recuperate as much as 90% to 95% of a battery’s parts.
Kendall stated lithium-ion batteries’ worst-case environmental influence  would nonetheless be lower than  fossil fuels’. 
“Whereas we definitely can enhance mining practices and recycling methods for each materials and product in our economic system, there are only a few measures whereby oil and gasoline extraction and refining are much less dangerous than lithium extraction (for electrical automotive batteries),” she stated.
A girl in an Instagram video claims California’s push for electrical automobiles just isn’t sustainable partially as a result of California doesn’t have a recycling facility that may deal with the lithium-ion batteries in automobiles and that the recycling services within the nation can recycle solely 10% of the batteries’ materials. 
Whereas California to date has no lithium-ion battery recycling plant, the California Environmental Safety Company report stated lithium-ion battery recycling remains to be a reasonably new trade with room for progress. Additionally, corporations from different states are partnering with California to recycle its batteries.
Moreover, present recycling strategies can recuperate from half to as much as 95% of the fabric used lithium-ion batteries, excess of the put up’s declare of a ten% restoration charge. 
We charge this declare False.
Workplace of Gov. Gavin Newsom, Governor Newsom Outlines Historic $10 Billion Zero-Emission Automobile Package deal to Lead the World’s Transition to Clear Power, Fight Local weather Change, Jan. 26, 2022
Instagram put up, June 16, 2022
Archive of June 16, 2022 Instagram put up
Instagram put up, June 9, 2022
Archive of June 9, 2022 Instagram put up
PolitiFact, "Can Californians Cost Electrical Vehicles Throughout Summer season Warmth," July 2, 2021
California Power Fee, Electrical Automobile Chargers in California, accessed Aug. 5, 2022
California Power Fee, Gentle-Responsibility Automobile Inhabitants in California, accessed Aug. 5, 2022
California Power Fee, Report Exhibits California Wants 1.2 Million Electrical Automobile Chargers by 2030, June 9, 2021
The San Francisco Chronicle, "California isn’t constructing sufficient charging stations for electrical automobiles," June 11, 2021
Federal Freeway Administration, President Biden, USDOT and USDOE Announce $5 Billion over 5 Years for Nationwide EV Charging Community, Made Attainable by Bipartisan Infrastructure Regulation, Feb. 10, 2022
CARFAX, How Lengthy Do Electrical Automotive Batteries Final, Oct. 26, 2021
Federal Freeway Administration, Common Annual Miles per Driver by Age Group, Could 31, 2022
BBC, "Electrical automobiles: What is going to occur to all of the lifeless batteries," April 27, 2021
NPR, "How a handful of metals might decide the way forward for the electrical automotive trade," March 13, 2022
Illinois Library, Battery Recycling: Battery recycling info, July 28, 2022
Orange County Register, "What occurs when thousands and thousands of electrical automotive batteries get outdated," Jan. 27, 2022
E-mail with Alissa Kendall, July 24, 2022
Redwood Supplies, Redwood Supplies creates the primary pathways for end-of-life electrical autos; kicks off in California, Feb. 17, 2022
CalEPA, Lithium-ion Automotive Battery Recycling Advisory Group Ultimate Report, March 16, 2022
CBC, Are EV batteries recyclable? Your questions answered, Could 28, 2022
Reuters, Explainer: Are lithium-ion batteries in EVs a fireplace hazard?, Aug. 23, 2021
The Ideas of the Fact-O-Meter
In a world of untamed discuss and pretend information, assist us arise for the info.
Signal me up
District of Columbia
1800 I Avenue NW
Washington, DC 20006
801 third St. S
St. Petersburg, FL 33701


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *